We remain fully operational and committed to serving your needs during the COVID-19 pandemic. CLICK HERE for information about our response to this public health emergency.

Call Today 805.658.7800
Our Legal Blog View Our Latest Posts

William M. Slaughter and Jeffrey J. Halfen Prevail after 29-Day Trial

William M. Slaughter and Jeffrey J. Halfen Prevail after 29-Day Trial

Cal-American Water suffered a stinging defeat after 29 days of trial. Following a slope failure which occurred on July 13, 2009, Cal-American filed suit against a Camarillo couple, Dan and Jennifer Driscoll. It alleged nearly $2,000,000.00 in damages related to slope repair which was occasioned by a broken 10-inch water main.

Cal-American alleged that the operation of a lightweight Bobcat which was driven over the pipeline was the cause of its failure. However, evidence was presented at trial establishing that Cal-American had experienced “number leaks due to aging asbestos cement pipes” pursuant to a report that was filed with the California Public Utilities Commission. Judge Kent Kellegrew issued a decision on February 15, 2017 in favor of the defendants finding no liability.

Cal-American’s damages were compounded because it took more than two and a half hours to shut off the broken pipeline. Although it was offered $500,000.00 in settlement, Cal-American rejected the settlement and proceeded to an adverse result at trial. Ultimately the court awarded $356,577.93 in costs to the defendants. The case has since been settled by a payment of $306,577.93 to defendants.